A LAYMAN'S VISION--11

Sunday, 10-28-07






Articles, Opinions and News
Invited Distinguished Scholar and Thought Leader
“A LAY MAN'S VISION------PART- 11"
Forward to a friend

“A LAY MAN'S VISION------PART- 11"

Major (R) Khalid Nasr







In a democratic society, political parties are expected to play a significant role in articulating citizen's aspirations, but unfortunately, our political leaders have no personal vision or agenda to improve the condition of a common man and to face the challenges in the geo-political environment. An individual’s death takes place when his soul leaves his body; which is unavoidable whereas; a nation dies when there is a leadership crises and no effective leader is on board to take over. The history of Pakistan is full of incidents when our political leadership invited army to intervene in state affairs. Starting from Ghulam Mohammad to Musharraf, the opposition and common men of Pakistan always welcomed take over by the army. There is a general misconception in an Army general's mind that the civilian leadership is corrupt and incompetent. To some extent this conception is right also. We can take examples of Benazir Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif. Now the people of Pakistan want a change towards a civilian led democracy. Pakistan has seen enough traumas in her life and needs a respite. Our Sohni Dharti is too precious to be left to opportunists and carpet baggers. Election campaign has already begun; however, the main crisis a common man faces is a regime that is not delivering what the people want: they want rule of law and improvement in the life of a common man, while preserving the citizens’ basic human rights. The country is chock full of political parties but not a single one of them has the vision and strategy to change the miserable condition of a common man, and to handle the issues that Pakistan is confronting. A deal between Musharraf and Benazir Bhutto runs afoul of the two basic fault lines that will determine the future of democracy in Pakistan. These require a balance between the:





Civil -Military relations in governance of the country; and
The moderate------- extremist division in the society.


The next two to three months are very crucial for redesigning Pakistan’s foreign policy. Pakistan will have to take a firm stand regarding her relations with U.S.A. After the so called restoration of democracy in Pakistan, things would not be all that easy for Gen.Musharraf. As a civilian president, Gen.Musharraf will be having more power and public trust in certain areas; but would also be facing some pressures regarding the foreign policy issues. The relations with USA, China and Iran will take a positive turn from Pakistan’s perspective. US interference in Pakistan's internal affairs and the violation of international boundary laws on our Western border would be strictly dealt with. Let us hope that in the coming scenario the "Troika” comprising, the President , the Prime Minister and the Army Chief will work under mutual trust, respect and coordination to bring Pakistan out of its current crises and be able to face the global challenges.



Major (R) Khalid Nasr is a Defence and Policy Analyst from Pakistan. He is also a Member, Pakistan Think Tank Advisory Board.







--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reader Comments: [post comment]

MAJOR(R)KHALID NASR

I FULLY ENDORSE THE COMMENTS BY MR JAMIL ZAIDI. PAKISTAN HAD BEEN MANIPULATED BY THE OPPORTUNISTS & CARPET BAGGERS.REPETED TAKE OVERS BY ARMY WAS BASICALLY DUE TO FAULT-LINE IN MIND-SET OF OUR POLITICIANS. THEY HAD ALWAYS BEEN DEPENDENT ON ARMY FOR THE SOLUTION OF THEIR PROBLEMS. CONSIDERING THE POLITICAL HISTORY OF BHARAT ( I WOULD PREFER TO USE THE WORLD BHARAT RATHER THAN INDIA FOR OBVIOUS REASONS), WE FIND NOT A SINGLE OCCASION WHEN THE POLITICIANS LOOKED UPON THEIR ARMY FOR THE SOLUTION OF THEIR POLITICAL ISSUES. I PERSONALLY FEEL THE NEED OF A PARADIGM SHIFT IN THE MIND- SET OF OUR POLITICIANS. THEY SHOULD BE MORE FLEXIBLE IN THEIR THINKING,THEY SHOULD ALLOW MORE SPACE TO THEIR OPPONENTS ,AND FINALLY THEY SHOULD ADOPT THE POLICY OF LIVE AND LET OTHERS LIVE PEACE FULLY . I THINK THIS CHANGE WOULD BE WELCOMED BY ARMY ALSO.GOD BLESS PAKISTAN.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

jamilzaidijamilzaidi

In fact the nature f this political malady is twofold inasmuch as Muslim Leadership (except for the Quaid) were not prepared for Independence; and quaid didn\'t make any bones out of this when he admitted\' I find nothing but counterfeit coins when I search my right & left pockets\'. He further went on to say,\'I and my typewriter made Pakistan\'. On the other hand, Mr Abdul Aziz Malwada warned in his letter addressed to the Quaid,\'Muslims are backward financially, intellectually, economically, and socio-politically, whereas Indian National Congress has taken them to the position where they are standing with their back to the wall after LUCKNOW PACT. Under the circumstances, Muslims would be left with no other option, but to ask for a separate homeland. For running its day-to-day affairs, they would be finding themselves helpless in the absence of political institutions, but for Army wherein they are present in sizeable number. Hence the affairs of this country per force would be run by Army\'. It is also a fact, that Muslims were represented by Army Officers in the Boundary Commission & Muslim troops were awaited badly to save Muslims from the masaccre in East Punjab etc. Whereas Quaid was given the lease of life just for one year (due to being in advanced stage of Tuberculosis)after partition, the political leadership was found wanting in intellectual acumen & moral fibre.Consequently the high-handedness of Ghulam Muhammad as Governor-General and the notorious Tamiz-ud-din case by Justice Munir laying down the law of necessity; which ultimately was to result in secession of East Pakistan. General Muhammad Ayyub Khan (assuming the title of Field Marshal against internationally accepted standards for this rank)indulged in all kinds of irregularities including the ones for which Captain (Retired)Gauhar Ayyub was well-known in the context of his connections with GANDHARA NDUSTRIES and his firing on Karachi mob,and the High-handedness shown against Miss Fatima Jinnah (sister of the Father of Nation)were by no means a credit to the country. Miss Jinnah\'s death in mysterious circumstances was also not a very happy reflection to the country. Thus started a trail of unfortunate events with Military Rule coupled with political incompetence of the Leadership, which was never allowed to grow. History is full of the names of Military Leaders like Ayyub Khan,Zia-ul-Haq, and Yahya Khan who was held finally responsible alongwith Z. A. Bhutto (starting the legacy of the so called Martial Law Administrators) who was hanged by General Zia-ul-Haq for the murder of late Mr Qasuri. Hence Pakistan became a political arena for adventurers both from the Civil and the Army. Society being the same, both sides excelled each other in political adventurism & gravest possible irregularities at the cost of national interests. Jameel Zaidi





--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of the Pakistan Think Tank Organization (PTT) or its members.

To become a Member of PTT, click here.

The PTT grants permission to cross-post original PTT articles on community internet sites as long as the text & title are not modified. The source and the author's copyright must be displayed. For publication of PTT articles in print or other forms including commercial internet sites, contact: agamjd@gmail.com

www.pakistanthinktank.org contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available to our readers under the provisions of "fair use" in an effort to advance a better understanding of political, economic and social issues. The material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving it for research and educational purposes. If you wish to use copyrighted material for purposes other than "fair use" you must request permission from the copyright owner.

Invitation: All original articles are welcome for the PTT Articles Section, please e-mail them to: agamjd@gmail.com
Latest Articles
“Reawakening of Pakistan”
Major (R) Khalid Nasr, Member Pakistan Think Tank Advisory Board

PROUD SON OF PAKISTAN: HARCHARAN SINGH GRADUATES FROM PMA
The Pakistan Think Tank Organization

INDIA'S JEWISH COMMUNITY OUTRAGED OVER “NAZI COLLECTION''
HON. EDOLPHUS TOWNS OF NEW YORK, IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ( COURTESY:Dr. Awatar S. Sekhon)

Starting again
Humayun Gauhar, The Nation, (Courtesy: The Brasstacks Organization)

Damned if he does
Barrister Babar Sattar,, LLM, Harvard Law, Rhodes Scholar and Pakistan Think Tank Distinguished Scholar and Thought Leader

Allah or Mullah
Abisafyan, Member Pakistan Think Tank Organization

DYSFUNCTIONAL EARLY EDUCATION
COL.(R) GHULAM WARRIS; Pakistan Think Tank Advisory Board, U.S.A.

Anatomy of October 19 Blasts
Adnan Gill, Defense and Political Analyst, U.S.A.

HOW PROSPEROUS IS THE INDIAN DEMOCRACY? IS IT THAT PROSPEROUS AS PUBLICIZED BY THE INTERNATIONAL NEWS MEDIA TYCOONS?
Awatar Singh Sekhon (Machaki), Ph D, FIBA, RM (CCM)

DEMONIZATION OF PAKISTAN BY THE AMERICAN PRESS & MEDIA 2007 PART 2: An Open Letter to NBC News-: A Riposte : Is Ambushing Iliterate Pakistanis by NBC fair journalism?
Dr.Mike Bax, Pakistan Think Tank Advisory Board

DEMONIZATION OF PAKISTAN BY THE AMERICAN PRESS & MEDIA 2007 Part1: Where the Jihad Lives Now - and A Riposte
NEWSWEEK COVER STORY, Courtesy: Newsweek and PTT Member: Faruq Khan, Riposte by Dr.Mike Bax

What has happened to our city, our home?
By Fatima Bhutto, Courtesy: The News,and Col.(R) Ghulam Warris

The Benazir factor
By M.B. Naqvi , Pakistan Think Tank Distinguished Journalist, Writer and Thought Leader

Hindutva terror in India
By Subhash Gatade, Courtesy: DR AWATAR SINGH SEKHON

Mohtarma, Wit and Wisdom
Col. Riaz Jafri (Retd), Distinguished Commentator and Thought Leader

Points to Ponder!
Navid Zafar, Distinguished Scholar. Courtesy: Col(R) Bakhtiar Hakeem

Benazir Bhutto, a kleptocrat in a Hermes scarf
By Jemima Khan, Former Mrs.Imran Khan, Courtesy: The London Telegraph and Brasstacks

Blackwater-Rise of a Mercenary Mafia with a legal cover
A.H Amin, Pakistan Think Tank Distinguished Scholar and Thought Leader

Benazir and the Green Revolution
BY GENERAL (RETD) MIRZA ASLAM BEG, The Chairman of FRIENDS, A Geostrategic Think Tank in Pakistan, Former COAS, Pakistan Army, Courtesy: Col.(R) Ghulam Warris

Pakistan, Building Our Future Today: Security SOPs & BB under Attack
Ali Safdar Jamshaid Khan; Pakistan Think Tank Opinion Leader

Benazir’s anti-Punjab card
By Humayun Gauhar, Courtesy: Brasstacks; THE NATION

Against the tide
M.P. Bhandara,Member, Pakistan National Assembly (With special permission to PTT, Courtesy: Col(R)G.Warris, Also Published in Dawn)

Perspective on national reconciliation
M.B. Naqvi , Distinguished Journalist and Opinion Leader, Pakistan Think Tank Organization

Hope versus scepticism
Barrister Babar Sattar, LLM, Harvard Law and Rhodes Scholar. Islamabad, Pakistan

Miscellaneous Internal and National Security, Religious Activism, Drugs, Politics and Terrorism Reports
Z.Hamid,Defence and Security Threat Analyst, The Brasstacks Organization, Islamabad

[ see all articles ]

Home : About Us : Forum : Articles : Links : Manage : Contact Us ©2007 Pakistan Think Tank, USA. All Rights Reserved.